Search for diamonds across many online retailers!
Retailer Ratings
Brilliant Earth, Founded in 2005
Brilliant Earth specializes in ethically sourced diamonds, offering both natural and lab-grown stones with a strong emphasis on sustainability and traceable sourcing.
What Reddit is Saying
Reddit discussion of Brilliant Earth is notably polarized: some owners love the designs, showroom experience, and finished appearance of their rings, and there are buyers who report years of trouble-free wear. At the same time, the retailer attracts a high volume of strongly negative posts about loose stones, broken prongs or bands, resizing and repair mistakes, production delays, and difficult warranty interactions. The recurring concern is less about finding an appealing design and more about confidence in long-term craftsmanship and after-sales service. Because of that pattern, Redditors frequently advise careful inspection, insurance, and comparison with a reputable local jeweler before committing.
👍 Positive
A 2026 owner shared a positive long-term experience, saying the ring had remained beautiful through engagement and marriage despite the negative stories they later read.
r/EngagementRings →Another buyer said the Brilliant Earth ring matched the design they had dreamed of and that they loved the finished piece.
r/EngagementRings →Even skeptical shoppers often say Brilliant Earth's settings and designs are unusually appealing and easy to browse online or view in showrooms.
r/EngagementRings →👎 Constructive
One resizing case reportedly stretched into a months-long ordeal and resulted in the customer's yellow-gold ring being altered to white gold.
r/EngagementRings →Multiple owners report prongs, settings, or bands breaking under normal wear and describe unsatisfying warranty or repair interactions afterward.
r/EngagementRings →Another highly discussed case described repeated production delays followed by continuing quality concerns with a pavé-heavy setting.
r/EngagementRings →AI-generated summary of public Reddit discussion, not affiliated with Reddit. Last updated 2026-08-22 · based on 7 discussions.